top of page

Three Doors, No Hallway : The Disconnect Between Company, Trademark and Domain Registration

7 minutes ago
10 min read

Introduction : A founder registers a company, gets a certificate from the Registrar of Companies, purchases a similar domain and prints the name on all their invoices. Two years later, a notice of law is delivered to the owner of a registered trademark that is similar, if not identical. The obvious answer that springs to mind of the founder is that the name was approved by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA). That's not an answer, Indian courts have recently said, that's just a response. 


This is because it is structurally based. In India, there are three distinct systems that govern a business name, which don't speak to each other. The Companies Act, 2013 provides for the right to incorporate under a name. The right to use the name as a brand is conferred by registering a trademark under the Trade Marks Act, 1999. Just a web address - that's all domain registration can provide. Different authorities keep each register, ask different questions and provide different types of protection. A name may go through one door and be blocked at another, with no hallways in between. 


In this blog, we will explore how that disconnect leads to trademark infringement via corporate names and business registrations. It outlines the statutory provisions, explains the approach of courts to conflicts between company names and trademarks, summarises the most important cases such as the recent Supreme Court decision in G4S's appeal in February 2026, and concludes with a checklist for anyone considering starting up a company with a name that could conflict with a trademark.


Legal Provisions


The Trade Marks Act, 1999


The term “mark” is broadly defined in the Trade Marks Act and a name may be a trademark, including a corporate or trade name. Then in Section 29, there is a section dealing with the consequences of infringing a registered trademark. There are three limbs that are important for this discussion. 


The first thing to note about section 29(5) is that it is limited to names. Use is infringing a registered trademark if it is used as a trade name, or as a component of a trade name or the name of a business concern, in connection with the sale of the goods or services for which the trademark is registered. This is known as a “no-fault” provision, as the owner does not have to establish the distinctiveness of the mark or likelihood of confusion on their own, only by proving identity of the name element and identity of the goods/services. 


Secondly, section 29(4) provides protection to marks which are reputed in India. If the name is the same or similar to the name used for different goods or services, the proprietor may still be successful if the use, without good reason, unfairly exploits the distinctive character or reputation of the mark. The concepts of dilution, tarnishment and free-riding are introduced into this limb. Thirdly, the common law action for passing off is in existence and is distinct from the statute. It exists and is protected by actual use, not by registration, so that the defendant's own registration does not bar him.


The Companies Act, 2013


The Companies Act tackles the same issue from the register's point of view. A company's name can be corrected if it is the same or closely similar to another name or a registered trademark under Section 16. Section 16(1)(a) provides the Central Government with the power to intervene if a name is too similar to the names of other companies and/or trademarks, and the provision does not expressly limit the period of time the government can wait before intervening. 


The registered proprietor of a trademark is entitled to apply for rectification under section 16(1)(b) within three years of incorporation of the company or its change of name. If a direction is given, the company will be expected to change its name within 6 months. This replaced the Companies Act, 1956, section 22, under which the Central Government had a mere 12 months to take action. The 2013 Act shifted its focus from trademark integrity to commercial identity as proprietors of the trademark have an express statutory avenue. 


The Companies (Incorporation) Fifth Amendment Rules, 2021, added Rule 33A, which provides for compliance. If a company does not change its name upon request, the name will be automatically edited to include the suffix "ORDNC" (Order of Regional Director Not Complied) and the year and the Corporate Identity Number.


The Third Register: Domain Names


There is no legislation connecting domain registration to either regime. The domain is assigned by a registrar on a first come first served basis and no reference is made to the Trade Marks Act or Companies Act. Disputes over the domain are thus governed by the same infringement and passing-off principles, and the G4S litigation below illustrates.


Legal Analysis


Why the Three Registers Cannot Protect One Another


The difference is best explained by looking at what each register is testing. In the process of registration, the MCA and the Registrar of Companies ask if the proposed name of the company is similar to another company name or to a registered trademark. Classification is key to the scope of protection because the Trade Marks Registry will compare the mark to other marks in the same class of goods/services. A domain registrar will only ask if the string exists. 


These questions vary from case to case, and approval by one means nothing to the other. Company name registration under the Companies Act does not give exclusive trademark rights and the company wishing to have trademark protection for their brand name will have to register it as a trademark separately. The corollary is the risk: a corporate name may be used as a company name and as a brand at the same time.


Three Infringement Scenarios


To organize the law, we need to look at 3 situations: 


In the first, the name of the company and the Registered Mark are similar or identical and the goods/services are also similar or identical. Section 29(5) will be relevant and an injunction is likely if both of the above elements can be established. Secondly, the registered mark is well known and company name is similar or identical, but business is in dissimilar goods/services. Where the second part of section 29(5) is not satisfied then section 29(4) is available to fill the void where the mark has a reputation. This is the Delhi High Court's finding in Bloomberg Finance LP v. Prafull Saklecha, which held that section 29(5) would not be the sole remedy for infringement through a company name. 


In the third, the registered mark does not have a particular reputation and the goods/services are dissimilar. Establishing trademark infringement is then difficult and, if the three year period has not elapsed, the proprietor's main remedy will be to have the company name corrected pursuant to section 16(1)(b) of the Companies Act. 


There is a split between High Courts in the second scenario. In RPG Enterprises Ltd. v. Riju Ghoshal, the Bombay High Court, after following Cipla Ltd. v. Cipla Industries Pvt. Ltd, ruled that section 29(5) was the only section which would govern the infringement by trade name. The defendants' opticals and their own pharmacies were not in the same class, so there was no infringement under that provision. However, the court determined that the defendants used the letters as logos and marks, not just as trade names, and found infringement under section 29(4). The safety harbour therefore cannot be assumed if a different class is found in a different business by a founder.


The MCA Approved It" Is Not a Defence


The greatest evidence of the disconnect is the dispute between G4S Limited, a global security services firm and an Indian firm that used the same trademark “4GS” and corporate names like “4 Group Safeguard & Security Services Private Limited”, as well as a matching domain name. The defendant contended that its name had been approved by the MCA and the Registrar of Companies, and that its domain had been registered by a registrar, therefore, if there was any grievance it was to be raised elsewhere. 


The Delhi High Court never accepted it. In April 2024, the single judge issued an interim injunction prohibiting the use of “4GS”, such as the “4gs” part of the domain name. In September 2025, one judge decided that MCA or ROC approval does not constitute a defence against infringement or passing off and called the case one of ‘triple identity' - namely, similar marks, identical services, and identical trade channels and customers. In December 2025, the Division Bench dismissed the appeal and on 13th February 2026, the Supreme Court dismissed the special leave petition, stating that the Special Court was dismissed on merits. 


The defendant's argument was essentially that one door was to be relied upon for the content of another. The courts rejected it because they address different questions.


The Company Law Route and Its Limits


Section 16 is a less expensive option for trademark owners than a traditional infringement action, but it has its limits. In T.T. Ltd. v. Union of India, the Madras High Court ruled that section 16(1)(a) is a power of the Central Government alone and hence, the private proprietors are required to avail of the power as provided in section 16(1)(b) and the three-year limitation. 

The court also decided that even the government has to act within a reasonable time, interpreted together with the previous 12 months' rule (section 22 of the 1956 Act). The registered office is the place of jurisdiction. The Regional Director whose territorial jurisdiction includes the Registrar of Companies where the company is registered, is before whom rectification proceedings are laid. Most importantly the Regional Director compares names only. 


In the case of Panchhi Petha Store vs Union of India, the Delhi High Court concluded that the Regional Director had stretched his authority in deciding who was the owner of the trademark. Ownership and infringement are issues before civil courts or IP tribunals and the writ jurisdiction of the High Court is limited to ensuring that the Regional Director acted lawfully and fairly. The remedies are then located in different fora and a founder may find himself in a battle on two fronts when he presents his rectification application and infringement action simultaneously.


The Stricter Test Under Company Law


Company law can be less forgiving than trademark law. In CGMP Pharmaplan (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, the petitioner contended that there was no finding of any deceptive similarity by the civil court. The Delhi High Court had concluded that under the company law, there is a much more stringent test: "close resemblance" will suffice, there is no requirement of actual confusion or the Regional Director will have to exercise his own discretion. The Madras High Court's judgement in Raymond Pharmaceuticals v. Union of India is consistent that the Companies Act is in a different field and that an injunction cannot be denied even if the name rectification remedy is not sought.


Relevant Case Laws


G4S Limited v. the 4GS entities (Delhi High Court, CS(COMM) 276/2024: Supreme Court SLP dismissed 13 February 2026): MCA or ROC approval of a corporate name is no defence to trademark infringement or passing off. The case also restrained the "4gs" element of a domain name and illustrates the "triple identity" approach.


Havells India Ltd. v. Havai Home Products Pvt. Ltd. (Delhi High Court, July 2026): A defendant's own trademark registration did not prevent a passing-off claim founded on prior use and goodwill, with the court examining how the mark was actually presented to consumers.


RPG Enterprises Ltd. v. Riju Ghoshal (Bombay High Court, 2022): Section 29(5) was treated as the only provision governing infringement through trade names, so use in a different class did not infringe under it. Infringement was nonetheless made out under section 29(4) because the letters were used as marks.


Shaktiman Equipments v. Union of India (Madras High Court, 2024): Identical names were ordered rectified in favour of a prior user of more than sixty years, even though the businesses were in different fields.


Kirloskar Diesel Recon Pvt. Ltd. v. Kirloskar Proprietary Ltd. (Bombay High Court, 1996): The own-name defence in what is now section 35 does not extend to an incorporated company, because a company adopts its name by choice.


Practical Implications


The lesson for the founders is that clearance must be obtained prior to incorporation, and on all three registers. The effects of not doing so are real: the expense of replacing the logo, signage, marketing, and the loss of goodwill cultivated under a challenging name. Having a similar domain name doesn't help either; as G4S demonstrates. The three year period in section 16(1)(b) is a reason why monitoring is essential for trademark proprietors. A proprietor can make use of the window by keeping regular monitoring of MCA name filings and trademark journals and can choose between section 29 and passing of, and section 16, depending on the limits of each forum. The stance of the High Courts is not consistent with regard to cross-class conflicts and advice on dissimilar-goods names should factor in the risk under section 29(4) as a possibility, especially for reputed marks.


Name-Clearance Checklist for Founders


  1. First, do a clearance search across IP India database for their brand name.

  2. Second, search the MCA’s company and LLP records.

  3. Third, check and confirm the availability of your desired domain name.

  4. Fourth, inspect the open market for unregistered users since goodwill alone can support passing off.

  5. Fifth, examine for deceptive similarity from the point of view of an average intelligence customer with imperfect recollection.


Conclusion


Three different questions are being answered by registration behind the doors of company, domain and trademark statutes; And no statutory hallway stands between them. A founder only gets the approval of a name by the MCA, under which they can exist. But that right doesn’t extend to the use of it as a brand. The G4S ruling by the supreme court clarified that trademark due diligence is not the same as regulatory approval or a domain brought in good faith. 


The Trademark Act has section 29 and passing off; Company act has section 16’s time limited rectification. The law has provided tools on both sides but ultimately, they live in different forums, with different tests and different deadlines. The burden to coordinate with each one of them is on the founder’s shoulders. They have to be the one who clears the name across all 3 registers and register their trademark early. And start the journey of brand protection from the incorporation certificate, rather thinking of it as an end. A reform worth considering would be an integrated search facility across the databases, which will remove much of the risk at source itself. 


Author: Chesta Chaurasia in case of any queries please contact/write back to us via email to content@khuranaandkhurana.com or at  Khurana & Khurana, Advocates and IP Attorney


Endnotes


  1. Trade Marks Act, 1999, s. 2(1)(m) (India).

  2. Trade Marks Act, 1999, s. 29(4) (India).

  3. Trade Marks Act, 1999, s. 29(5) (India).

  4. Trade Marks Rules, 2002, Fourth Schedule (India).

  5. Companies Act, 2013, ss. 4, 16 (India).

  6. Companies Act, 1956, s. 22 (India) (repealed).

  7. Companies (Incorporation) Fifth Amendment Rules, 2021, r. 33A (India).

  8. Cipla Ltd. v. Cipla Industries Pvt. Ltd., AIR 2017 Bom 75 (India).

  9. Raymond Pharmaceuticals v. Union of India, 2022 SCC OnLine Mad 5610 (India).

  10. Bloomberg Finance LP v. Prafull Saklecha, (2014) 207 DLT 35 (Del) (India).

  11. Havells India Ltd. v. Havai Home Products Pvt. Ltd. (Del, July 2026) (India).

  12. RPG Enterprises Ltd. v. Riju Ghoshal (Bom, 21 March 2022) (India).

  13. G4S Ltd. v. 4GS entities, CS(COMM) 276/2024 (Del) (India).

  14. T.T. Ltd. v. Union of India, 2022 SCC OnLine Mad 9527 (India).

  15. Panchhi Petha Store v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine Del 8188 (India).

  16. CGMP Pharmaplan (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, 2010 SCC OnLine Del 2387 (India).

  17. Shaktiman Equipments v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine Mad 11796 (India).

  18. Kirloskar Diesel Recon Pvt. Ltd. v. Kirloskar Proprietary Ltd. (Bom 1996) (India).


Comments


bottom of page