Limitation Periods in Long-Term Supply Contracts: Accrual, Acknowledgement and the Case for Periodic Reconciliation
Introduction : When there is a long-term supply relationship (whether this is through a master supply agreement, rate contract or annual purchase orders) this will create an ongoing supply situation. The parties will often assume that as long as they are dealing with each other, then there is no problem in recovering the oldest outstanding invoices. However, this is not the case under the Limitation Act, 1963. There is a time limit starting from the accrual of each Cause of action, and simply having an ongoing relationship will not prevent this.
The Limitation Act creates a bar to the remedy that the court must apply even if it has not been pleaded by the defendant. If the supplier has a good claim, they could lose it as there will be no record of when the clock started to run. Only certain events will reset the clock. These are a written acknowledgement signed (Section 18), partial payment with written acknowledgement (Section 19) and ongoing breach (Section 22). This blog outlines the relevant provisions, looks at accruals, acknowledgements, partial payments, ongoing obligations and running accounts. It also outlines leading cases and looks at why regular reconciliation and claims tracking will help maintain the right to recover debts.
Legal Provisions
A. The Limitation Act, 1963
Section 3(1) states that any suit brought after the period of limitation has expired must be dismissed. However, this is not a defence. Section 9 states that if time has started to run then no subsequent disability or inability to bring a suit will affect this.
For goods sold and delivered, the Schedule prescribes three years. Under Article 14, where no fixed period of credit is agreed, time runs from delivery; under Article 15, where the price is payable after a fixed credit period, from the expiry of that period. Article 55 applies to breach of a contract not otherwise provided for, and time runs from the breach or, where breaches are successive, from the breach sued upon, or, where the breach is continuing, from when it ceases. Article 1 applies to the balance due on a mutual, open and current account with reciprocal demands, and time runs from the close of the year in which the last admitted or proved item is entered.
Section 18 provides that where, before the prescribed period expires, an acknowledgement of liability is made in writing and signed by the party against whom the right is claimed, a fresh period is computed from the date of signing. The Explanation states that an acknowledgement may suffice although it does not specify the exact nature of the right, states that the time for payment has not come, is accompanied by a refusal to pay, or is coupled with a claim to set-off, and that signature by a duly authorised agent suffices. Section 19 provides that a payment on account of a debt, made before expiry by the person liable or his authorised agent, starts a fresh period from the date of payment, provided an acknowledgement of the payment appears in the payer's handwriting or in a writing signed by the payer. Section 22 provides that in the case of a continuing breach of contract a fresh period begins at every moment during which the breach continues.
B. The Indian Contract Act, 1872
Section 25(3) renders enforceable, without consideration, a promise made in writing and signed by the person to be charged to pay wholly or in part a debt of which the creditor might have enforced payment but for the law of limitation. Sections 59 to 61 regulate the application of payments among several debts: the debtor may appropriate at the time of payment, failing which the creditor may do so, and where neither does, the payment is applied in order of time, whether or not the debts are barred by limitation.
Legal Analysis
A. Accrual Is Invoice-Specific
Legal Analysis
A master supply agreement will govern individual sales. Each shipment and invoice will create individual debts. The accrual of these debts will be determined by either delivery or the end of the agreed credit period (Articles 14 and 15). Continuance of business under section 9 will not suspend the running of the limitation period.
If goods are supplied on 1 April 2024 with a sixty-day credit period, this will expire on 31 May 2024. The limitation period will therefore commence on this date (excluding the day itself) and a claim for price must generally be issued by 31 May 2027. This period will not be extended due to invoicing in subsequent months. If some invoices are paid and others not, each invoice will have its own expiry date. Only the oldest of the outstanding invoices will lapse.
It may be argued that where there is a supply relationship between the parties under one contract, this creates one debt and the limitation period will not commence until the last default. This will be difficult to align with Articles 14 and 15 which provide that each sale and shipment will be limited in time and article 55 which considers the specific breach for which the claim is being made. This does not affect the limitation periods on individual debts, but just the relationship and evidence of business between the parties.
B. Acknowledgement (Section 18)
Section 18 provides the main ground for extending a trade debt. The Supreme Court has held that the acknowledgement must relate to an existing liability, show some juristic relationship between the parties (debtor and creditor) and evidence an intention to acknowledge a relationship between them at the time the statement is made. There is no need to provide any promise to pay or exact amount owed but it must be in writing, signed by the party who owes the debt or their authorised agent and before the limitation period has expired.
In relation to supply contracts, this would be most clearly satisfied by a reconciliation statement signed by the buyer acknowledging a balance owing. An invoice, challan or unsigned statement from the supplier will not be sufficient as it must be in writing from the party from whom the right is being claimed. Simply referencing previous dealings will not be enough.
Entries on a balance sheet have caused the most issues. In Bishal Jaiswal the Supreme Court held that this could be considered to be an acknowledgement under section 18 depending on the facts of the situation. However, this has been criticised in some areas. In IL&FS Financial Services Ltd v Adhunik Meghalaya Steels Pvt Ltd the Court applied this principle to a signed balance sheet alongside other documents. The creditor was not mentioned in the balance sheet. These cases were both under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. There must still be an existing liability and juristic relationship.
C. Part Payment (Section 19) & Appropriation
Section 19 is very restrictive. Payment must be made towards the debt before the limitation period expires by the person owing the debt or their authorised agent. The payment must be acknowledged by writing in the handwriting of the payer or signed writing. If payment has been made into a bank, this alone may not satisfy the proviso. If the buyer makes a payment towards multiple invoices, the supplier should receive a signed advice note to show which invoices the payment relates to. Absent appropriation by either party, section 61 of the Indian Contract Act applies the payment to the oldest debts, which may already be barred.
D. Recurring Obligations and Continuing Breach
Section 22 is often applied in circumstances where non-payment of a long term contract is considered to be an ongoing breach. However, the Supreme Court has clarified the difference between an ongoing wrong and a self contained wrong. The non-payment of an invoice would be a completed breach of contract on the due date of payment. Section 22 would be more likely to apply if there was a requirement to continually perform obligations under the contract such as a covenant to deliver goods on a monthly basis throughout the duration of the contract or provide ongoing services. This will be a matter of construction and therefore claims for the price of goods supplied will usually be subject to Articles 14 and 15.
E. Running Accounts Under Article 1
This only applies to mutual, open and current accounts where there are demands from both parties. Whilst one party may be owed money from the other, they will also owe the other party money at various points due to independent transactions. If there is a one-way account with invoices from supplier to buyer and payments made by the buyer, then this would not be a mutual account. If the supplier also buys goods from the customer, then Article 1 could apply. However, it will depend on the nature of the relationships and cannot be assumed.
F. Claims Already Barred
Sections 18 and 19 only apply before the expiry of the period. An acknowledgement signed after this period will not revive the debt. However, there is an alternative available under section 25(3) of the Indian Contract Act. This makes any signed written promise to pay a time-barred debt enforceable. This is different to an acknowledgement of liability. Therefore, if a supplier wants to claim under section 25(3), they should ensure there is a clear promise to pay.
Case Laws
Hindustan Forest Co v Lal Chand, AIR 1959 SC 1349: The Supreme Court held that dealings between a buyer and a seller of goods did not form a mutual, open and current account with reciprocal demands, as there were no independent obligations in both directions. It is the authority that a one-way supply and payment relationship does not attract the provision now numbered Article 1.
Balakrishna Savalram Pujari Waghmare v Shree Dhyaneshwar Maharaj Sansthan, AIR 1959 SC 798: Decided under section 23 of the Limitation Act, 1908, the predecessor of section 22, the judgment distinguishes a continuing wrong, which is a continuing source of injury, from a wrong complete when committed whose consequences persist. Only the former gives a fresh period at each moment of continuance.
Sampuran Singh v Niranjan Kaur, (1999) 2 SCC 679: The Supreme Court examined section 18 and held that the statement must relate to a subsisting liability and indicate a jural relationship, and that the section does not operate on an acknowledgement made after the period has expired.
Asset Reconstruction Co (India) Ltd v Bishal Jaiswal, (2021) 6 SCC 366: The Supreme Court held that section 18 applies to applications under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, and that balance sheet entries may constitute an acknowledgement, the question depending on the facts of each case.
IL&FS Financial Services Ltd v Adhunik Meghalaya Steels Pvt Ltd, 2025 INSC 911: The Supreme Court held that an entry in the signed balance sheet for the financial year 2019 to 2020, read with surrounding financial documents, was a valid acknowledgement although the creditor was not named, and set aside the order of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal holding the petition time-barred.
Practical Implications
A. Reconciliation as a Limitation Control
To ensure the balance is secured as evidence with a signed reconciliation statement, a fresh 3 year limitation period can start from the date of an 'acknowledgement’ under section 18. This document should include the period relating to the reconciliation, invoice numbers, dates, credit terms, payments applied and credit notes issued. It should also include the exact balance outstanding and an undertaking from the buyer that this is currently owing. The document should also be signed by an [authorised signatory]. Any wording that indicates this is subject to final reconciliation will reduce the strength of the document. Disputed balances should be noted in a separate section so that the limitation dates of those invoices are not affected.
The question of using an email should be avoided. Under section 5 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 electronic signatures are recognised. It would be the safest option to use either an electronic version of a statement or a paper version with a signature from the buyer.
B. Claims Tracking
As limitation applies separately for each invoice, it would be a risk management tool to have a claims register in place. The register should show for each receivable the contractual obligation/purchase order, invoice number, date, delivery date, proof of delivery, credit terms, date due, net balance, calculated date of expiry, date of and document of any acknowledgements and partial payments. The review dates should be well in advance of the expiry of the balance. A demand notice will not stop time running; however, the plaint will be served, and this is the point at which time stops. If an arbitration is being used, the date the respondent received the arbitration request. Any payments made against an old balance should be reviewed by the legal/credit department to ensure deliberate appropriation under sections 59-61 of the Indian Contract Act.
C. Drafting and Policy Considerations
The supply agreement may contain clauses stating that each invoice will be treated as a separate debt, that there will be regular reconciliations, the order in which payments will be allocated and that a signed statement of account will be treated as an acknowledgement. These will help but will not override the statute. The document will only have the effect of an acknowledgement if it contains certain content and a signature. There are two policy issues to consider. Firstly, whether entries in the statutory accounts should be treated as acknowledgements. This has been agreed in the case of Bishal Jaiswal but has been debated in commentary. Secondly, there is no mention of how electronic acknowledgements should be carried out.
Conclusion
A continuous supply relationship will not restart the limitation period for previous unpaid invoices. Each invoice related to a delivery will be treated as a separate debt with its own accrual date. As limitation has started to run, nothing can stop it under section 9 of the Limitation Act, 1963. The only way the limitation period can be restarted is by a written signed acknowledgement (section 18), a written partial payment (section 19) or continuing breach (section 22). None of these will restart a claim that has expired. The only remaining method would be a signed undertaking under section 25(3) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Regular signed reconciliations and having a claims register to note the accrual and expiry dates for each receivable will help implement these rules. Two changes could be considered. Firstly, to clarify how electronic acknowledgements should be carried out under section 18. Secondly, guidance on how much weight should be given to the balance sheet entries as they are being done to meet a statutory obligation.
Author: Akshaya Macharla in case of any queries please contact/write back to us via email to content@khuranaandkhurana.com or at Khurana & Khurana, Advocates and IP Attorney




Comments