Influencer Marketing and Consumer - Protection Compliance: Disclosure, Product Claims and Contractual Responsibility under Indian Law
Introduction : The way in which brands market their products and consumers decide on what to purchase has changed due to social media. Companies tend to work with influencers, content creators, celebrities and people who are active online in order to market products or services using Instagram posts, videos on YouTube, videos, blogs, livestreams and affiliate marketing. Different from the traditional form of advertisements, the influencer marketing strategy is often presented in the form of a recommendation, review or daily experience that seems more credible to the audience.
Nevertheless, being of a commercial type, the practice of influencer marketing entails certain legal obligations. In case an influencer is getting paid for, or gets gifts, discounts, commissions or other favors in return for recommending a product, there may be some influence on the way the consumers perceive the recommendation. If it goes unnoticed, or the influencer makes any unrealistic claims, the consumers will be misled into buying the product.
The law in India tackles these issues using the Consumer Protection Act, 2019; the Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements for Misleading Advertisements, 2022; and the relevant advertising standards set out under the Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI). Under these guidelines, advertisements must be truthful; the disclosures should be sufficiently clear; and endorsements should represent authentic views based on adequate information or experience.
Influencer marketing thus poses three legal issues that need to be answered. The first issue is whether and how the influencer needs to disclose a business connection with the brand. The second issue is what proof should be gathered prior to making claims about the performance or quality of the product. The third issue concerns liability among all parties. This paper attempts to analyse the relevant laws of India, judicial rulings, and provide a campaign clearance system that is feasible in nature.
Legal Provisions
Consumer Protection Act, 2019: Misleading Advertisements
Section 2(1) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 provides a broad definition of advertisement that includes representations and endorsements made through electronic media, including audio or visual publicity, the internet, or websites. Thus, influencer advertising may be considered under the statutory definition of advertisement even when presented through social media posts.
Section 2(28) of the Act defines misleading advertisement in connection with a product or service. In general terms, the definition includes any advertisement that gives a false description of the product, makes false guarantees, is likely to mislead the consumer about the product's nature, substance, quantity, and quality, makes representations that constitute unfair trade practice, or conceals material information. The section becomes more significant where the influencer advertises the product as scientifically proven, assures certain results from the product, makes claims of zero risks, and states that it is superior to other competing products.
Powers of the Central Consumer Protection Authority
Under Section 10 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) is established, and it has powers to protect and enforce the rights of consumers and prevent any form of misleading advertisements. The responsibilities and powers of the CCPA are described in Section 18, where it can take action in case of misleading advertisements and unfair trade practices. According to Section 21, the CCPA has powers to order the discontinuation or modification of a misleading advertisement. In addition, there are penalties for the manufacturers and endorsers for failing to adhere to these laws, and they include a penalty of up to ₹10 lakh for the first contravention and up to ₹50 lakh for subsequent contraventions. Also, if necessary, an endorser can be stopped from endorsing any product or service for a period of up to one year for the first contravention and up to three years for subsequent contraventions.
Under Section 21(5), there is provision for defending an endorser, where he/she has done due diligence in verifying the claims made in the advertisement. This shows that the process of due diligence by an influencer is important. In addition, Section 89 imposes criminal liability on manufacturers or providers of services for making a false or misleading advertisement that is detrimental to the interests of consumers. The section may be pertinent to the entire advertising agreement depending on the circumstances of the case.
CCPA Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements, 2022
The Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements for Misleading Advertisements, 2022, have been made by the CCPA under Section 18 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. These guidelines set out the conditions for lawful advertising and endorsements, which include the following requirements: advertisements must not be misleading, disclaimers must not hide any material facts, and endorsements must be genuine and well-informed. Due diligence of endorsers is also considered in these Guidelines. An endorsement must express the genuinely held and current opinion, belief, finding or experience of the person making the endorsement, based on sufficient knowledge or experience with the product or service concerned. An endorsement must not, in any way, be misleading.
This is important because an influencer cannot simply use his/her right to absolve himself/herself from liability by claiming that the statement was provided by the brand. Various factors may come into play.
ASCI Code and Influencer Advertising Guidelines
The Association of the Advertising Industry (ASCI) is the regulatory body for advertisers in India. The Code and Guidelines for Influencer Advertising in Digital Media provide practical criteria for determining what is commercial content and whether the advertisement is accurate and differentiated from editorial content. In the guidelines on influencers of ASCI, the definition of material relationship is wide. It may cover any type of remuneration, gift, free or discounted products or services, travel, hotel accommodation, benefits from the competition, affiliate marketing programs, or a familial or employment relationship. Disclosure might be necessary even if the reviewer was not asked for the promotion of the product and the review was made independently.
Guidelines recommend disclosure labels to be clear, obvious, meaningful and adequate to the medium. The recognised labels include terms like Advertisement, Ad, Sponsored, Collaboration, Partnership, Employee, Free Gift and Affiliate, depending on the respective ASCI guidelines. Disclosure which is concealed behind hashtags, is contained only in profile bio or becomes available by clicking on "more" will not be appropriate. Standards developed by ASCI are self-regulatory and not legislation. However, they represent an important standard of compliance for brands, agencies and influencers running digital advertising campaigns.
Legal Analysis
Disclosure Requirements and Sponsored Content
Disclosures serve the core objective of ensuring that the consumer distinguishes between an influencer’s independent opinion and commercial communication. The product review may seem like the personal recommendation of the influencer, but a disclosure about whether the influencer is paid or benefits otherwise may influence consumer perception of the content. For instance, if an influencer gets paid to promote a skincare product, they cannot present the content in such a way that hides the commercial aspect. Likewise, the influencer getting a free smartphone, a free hotel stay or a discounted product may require the influencer to make the disclosure when posting the content, even though the brand does not explicitly request the review.
The disclosure should be sufficiently clear for any ordinary consumer to tell that the content is promotional. The disclosure should typically appear at the beginning of the caption or in the most visible part of the visual content. In the case of video content, the disclosure should be visible, whereas, in audio promotions, the disclosure should come audibly. In the case of livestream, the disclosure should be made in a way that reaches consumers joining later on in the stream. The form of the disclosure is equally important as the wording of the same. An easy-to-understand term like "#Ad" is much better than one that only hints at the involvement with a certain brand. In addition, there could be a general disclaimer on the profile of an influencer, mentioning that some posts may be sponsored. Such a disclaimer will not indicate that each post is commercial in nature.
There is no issue of misleading only when a deliberately misleading statement has been made. The problem of misleading can arise due to omission as well, as there might be no information about the material commercial connection with the brand among the audience.
Affiliate Links, Discount Codes and Commission-Based Promotions
Affiliate marketing brings up another issue of disclosure. The influencer would provide links for products, referral codes or purchasing links and get a reward if the consumer purchases the item. While an affiliate posting does not necessarily include the payment that the influencer gets for creating the post, his or her incentive may still affect the product recommendation. The consumer will approach the recommendation differently if he or she knows about the commercial incentives behind the recommendation. Hence, affiliate marketing posts need to disclose their nature properly. Such a disclosure may look like “Affiliate link: I may get paid commission for your purchase via this link.” In case of sponsored content, the disclosure needs to cover both aspects.
Discount codes also need to be disclosed properly. Since the influencer gets a commission each time someone uses the code to buy the product, such a discount code may not be viewed as an independent consumer benefit. Moreover, the consumer needs to know about all the terms of such an offer. The disclosure needs to be done close to where the recommendation or purchase is made, rather than only being made in long terms and conditions. This is applicable even to blogs, product descriptions, or live streaming. Affiliate marketing is not illegal per se. The danger is posed by keeping the commercial motive hidden, making deceptive recommendations, or distorting the conditions for purchase.
Substantiation of Product Claims
Brands and influencers frequently make claims regarding the effectiveness of the product, performance, safety, quality, price, and expected outcome. In case claims are objectively verifiable, then such claims must be backed by reliable evidence and may influence consumers' decision to purchase.
For instance, claims like a certain supplement increases the body's immunity within seven days; a certain cosmetic eliminates pigmentation forever; a coaching institute provides selection guarantee, and a product is twice as good as other competing products must not be made only for the reason that they seem appealing in the advertisement copy. The evidence to be provided varies from claim to claim. Some claims may need studies or testing; some may even require regulatory approval or the support of an expert. Comparative claims must have a reasonable basis and must also be comparative in nature.
The influencer cannot consider any assertion to be lawful just because it has been provided by the brand itself. The CCPA 2022 Guidelines mandate diligence on the part of the endorsers, while the ASCI Code mandates that objectively ascertainable claims must be capable of substantiation. There are considerations for visual presentation as well. Filtering, editing, and before-and-after shots/demonstrations may make an implied claim about the product even when the caption does not make an express representation. Using a filter that overstates the benefits of a skincare product, for example, may amount to false representation of its capabilities. A disclaimer will not save a misleading headline or visual per se. In case the headline or visual creates an exaggerated impression of benefit, then a disclaimer at the end of the post may not help.
Allocation of Responsibility Between Brands and Influencers
Influencer marketing campaigns typically require cooperation between the following parties: the advertiser, the influencer, the advertising agency, the talent manager, the affiliate network, and at times even the digital platform. Although each of them plays its own role in the process, one needs to differentiate the role of the party from the question of its legal responsibilities. The brand will normally be the one who controls the information about the product, permissible claims, the goals of the campaign and the evidence thereof. This means that the brand must make sure that the claims it provides are accurate and can be substantiated. The influencer is responsible for honest presentation of the promotion and avoiding unsubstantiated claims. The agency will possibly prepare the content, coordinate its approval and monitor the publication. The affiliate network will control the links, the tracking and disclosure of commissions.
Consumer Remedies and Regulatory Consequences
Non-compliance with the influencer marketing could result in repercussions other than the deletion of the social media post. Depending upon the circumstances, the advertisement could be sent to ASCI for self-regulation, investigated by CCPA, contested using the consumer protection procedure, or subjected to civil actions. In accordance with section 21 of the Consumer Protection Act, the CCPA could order for the discontinuance or modification of the advertisement along with imposing the statutory sanctions against the manufacturer or endorser of the advertisement. Section 89 would also come into play if the statutory criteria for false or misleading advertisement prejudicing the interests of consumers is met.
Consumers would also have the option of availing themselves of relief under the Consumer Protection Act if the criteria for filing a complaint are fulfilled. The availability and extent of remedy would depend upon the circumstances, the nature of representation, the loss or injury caused, and the statutory provisions involved. The above consequences show why compliance should start before the advertisement is published. The correction of a misleading marketing campaign even after it has been seen by thousands of consumers might not prevent the repercussions of the initial communication.
Case Laws
1. Marico Limited v. Abhijeet Bhansali, AIRONLINE 2020 BOM 3109
Facts: Marico Limited, the maker of the Parachute brand, had filed the suit against Abhijeet Bhansali, a social media influencer, for the publication of a video that had made some comments against the Parachute Coconut Oil.
Decision and Significance: While deciding on 15 January 2020, the Bombay High Court's Single Judge had viewed the commentary made by the influencer as a separate phenomenon of the commercial and social media world and examined the comments made in the video. The case also brought up issues of accountability that came along with influencing a large audience. In February 2020, the case was heard by the Division Bench on the appeal and interim relief.
The significance of this case lies in the fact that influencer content can cause legal action to be taken against it even in cases where the content is nothing more than a product review instead of an advertisement.
Limitation: First and foremost, this was not a decision that held that every influencer has to back up his/her every single personal view in the same way in which a paid ad needs to be backed up. Also, this case cannot be said to be one where the decision of the Single Judge can be seen as a final law which applies to every case of influencer speech.
2. Dabur India Ltd. v. Colortek Meghalaya Pvt. Ltd.
Facts: There was an advertisement for Good Knight Naturals mosquito repellent cream and Dabur claimed that it defamed its competitor Odomos' product.
Decision and Significance: In its judgment dated 2 February 2010, the Delhi High Court upheld the advertisement. It held that the commercial advertisement is covered by commercial speech. However, the advertisement must not be false, misleading, unfair, or deceptive. Moreover, it distinguishes between comparative advertisements that are true and disparaging untruths.
The significant rule is that a businessman can advertise his product and make comparisons, but he must have a factual basis for making objective statements. The statement about the superiority, safety, and effectiveness of the product cannot be taken as automatically acceptable only because it is a promotional one.
This rule is directly applicable to the influencer campaign. When an influencer makes a comparison between two products and states that the product sponsored by him works better than the competitive products, it must keep the evidence supporting such comparison.
Citation clarification: The above citation in the report needs to be verified prior to its publication with the report series. The well-known Delhi High Court case cited is that of Dabur India Ltd. v. Colortek Meghalaya Pvt. Ltd., FAO (OS) No. 625 of 2009, delivered on 2nd February 2010. Care must be taken not to confuse it with any Supreme Court case with the same citation.
3. Indian Medical Association v. Union of India, W.P. (C) No. 645 of 2022, order dated 7 May 2024, 2024 INSC 406
Facts: The cases were initiated because of misleading advertisements for Patanjali Ayurved products and the obligations of persons responsible for marketing such products. The litigation looked into misleading health-related advertisements and the importance of adhering to the legal framework regarding consumer protection.
Decision and Relevance: The proceedings demonstrated the importance of preventing misleading health-related advertisements and adhering to the legal framework concerning endorsements and consumer protection.
The decision is relevant for influencer campaigns for health and wellness, as well as any other products that are dependent on promotional representations by the consumers.
Limitation: It should be interpreted in light of the procedure in which it was made. It does not constitute a general ruling that determines all influencers' responsibility regarding misleading claims. All the instructions and conclusions concerning a particular party should be confirmed based on the specific order for it to be used in legal proceedings.
Altogether, the cases illustrate that any promotion and representation of products in the online environment must be reviewed in the context of their content, commercial context and the supporting evidence. The legislation on misleading advertisements constitutes the primary norm that should be followed.
Practical Implications
A Campaign-Clearance Process
Structured review prior to publishing will help to prevent misleading messages, lack of disclosures and contractual issues. It is recommended to apply the following procedure by brands and influencers.
Establish the nature of the commercial relationship. Document whether the content is sponsored through compensation, free products, discounts, affiliate commissions, travel arrangements, employment or any other substantial connection and establish what disclosures should be made on each platform used.
Check the product claims. Compile the list of all express and implied claims that are made within the content. Assess the truthfulness of performance, safety, health, quality, comparative and discount claims with relevant evidence. Exclude claims that cannot be properly supported.
Evaluate the creative content. Assess captions, scripts, demonstrations, filters, edited photos, before-and-after shots and disclosures. Make sure that the overall message is not misleading and disclosure is visible/audible.
Get the necessary contract approvals. Ensure that approved claims, disclosure language, review procedure, release dates and correction obligations are confirmed. Make sure that the influencer has sufficient information about claims made.
Publish and monitor. Test the published content to confirm the accuracy of any disclosures on the desired website or device. Monitor any complaints about false claims, faulty affiliate links, or any updates made to the product. Remove or fix any problematic content, where required.
Save the evidence. Keep the approved script, the final creative, the substantiation material, screenshots of disclosures, approvals from contracts and correspondence. This information could help in proving that verification had been done.
Campaign-Clearance Checklist
Compliance question | Action required |
Is there a material connection? | Identify payments, gifts, discounts, commissions and other benefits. |
Is the disclosure clear? | Use an appropriate, prominent and understandable label. |
Are product claims supported? | Retain evidence for factual, scientific and comparative statements. |
Are visuals accurate? | Review filters, editing, demonstrations and before-and-after images. |
Are contractual duties defined? | Specify approval, correction, monitoring and indemnity arrangements. |
Is the live post compliant? | Verify the actual published content across relevant formats. |
Are records preserved? | Retain contracts, claim evidence, approvals and publication records. |
This checklist should be adapted to the nature of the product, the platform, the intended audience and any sector-specific requirements. Additional review may be necessary for food, healthcare, medicines, financial services, education, environmental claims and other regulated areas.
Policy Considerations
The business of influencer marketing lies at the crossroads of commercial messaging, consumer trust, and digital communication. In light of the rising popularity of short-form content, live streaming, virtual influencers, and algorithm-driven promotions, consumers find it increasingly difficult to differentiate between personal recommendations and commercial messages.
First, disclosure rules need to remain comprehensible and universal. Clear rules regarding how affiliate links, gifted items, live streams, and virtual influencers are treated will allow consumers to recognise commercial relationships without the need to understand complex legalese. Second, businesses need to pursue evidence-based advertising. Statements made about the product being advertised should be checked before the commissioning of the content, not after the occurrence of a complaint. This is especially true when the product in question involves people's health, safety, or education.
Thirdly, contracts should assign duties in practical terms without trying to pass on all the responsibility for compliance to the influencer. The brands are usually the right people to provide product information and substantiation, while the influencers will be accountable for the way in which they promote the brand. Agencies should put in place appropriate procedures for approving promotions and escalating issues.
Lastly, the enforcement process should take into account whether there was intentional deception, insufficient disclosure, the expression of an honest opinion, or a mere mistake. There is a need for accountability for consumer protection, but at the same time the expression of genuine reviews needs to be maintained.
Conclusion
Influencer marketing is more than a sponsorship agreement between a company and a creator. It is a means of communicating a commercial message which may fall under the ambit of advertising regulations, consumer protection laws and contract requirements. In India, the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 and the 2022 Guidelines of the CCPA deal with misleading advertisements and endorsements, while ASCI guidelines lay down the norms for digital advertising.
There are three essential considerations that must be made. First, any significant commercial connections should be revealed upfront. Secondly, product claims should be genuine and sufficiently substantiated. Lastly, brands, influencers and agencies should spell out their respective responsibilities in writing. A clearance process for the campaign, which determines commercial relationships, verifies product claims, examines the creative, gets the approvals and tracks the publication of posts, can significantly help to mitigate legal and reputational risks. Ultimately, it is about the ability of consumers to understand the commercial purpose of an advertisement.
Author: Khushi Rawat in case of any queries please contact/write back to us via email to content@khuranaandkhurana.com or at Khurana & Khurana, Advocates and IP Attorney
Endnotes
Consumer Protection Act 2019, ss 2(1), 2(28), 18 and 21; Central Consumer Protection Authority, Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements for Misleading Advertisements, 2022; Advertising Standards Council of India, Guidelines for Influencer Advertising in Digital Media. See also Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Press Information Bureau, ‘Centre issues “Guidelines on Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements for Misleading Advertisements, 2022”’ (10 June 2022), available at: https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1832906&lang=2®=48.
Consumer Protection Act 2019, s 2(1) (definition of ‘advertisement’) and s 2(28) (definition of ‘misleading advertisement’). See India Code, Consumer Protection Act, 2019, available through the Department of Consumer Affairs: https://consumeraffairs.gov.in/pages/consumer-protection-acts.
Consumer Protection Act 2019, ss 10, 18 and 21(1)–(3).
Consumer Protection Act 2019, s 89.
Central Consumer Protection Authority, Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements for Misleading Advertisements, 2022, particularly the provisions on misleading advertisements, disclaimers and endorsements. The Guidelines were issued under s 18 of the Consumer Protection Act 2019.
Advertising Standards Council of India, Guidelines for Influencer Advertising in Digital Media, available at: https://www.ascionline.in/the-asci-code-guidelines/. See also ASCI, The ASCI Code, available at: https://www.ascionline.in/the-asci-code/.
Consumer Protection Act 2019, s 2(28); Advertising Standards Council of India, Guidelines for Influencer Advertising in Digital Media.
Central Consumer Protection Authority, Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements for Misleading Advertisements, 2022; Advertising Standards Council of India, The ASCI Code, Chapter I, particularly the requirements concerning truthful and honest representations and substantiation of claims.
Marico Limited v. Abhijeet Bhansali, AIRONLINE 2020 BOM 3109 (Bombay High Court, 15 January 2020); Abhijeet Bhansali v. Marico Limited, Commercial Appeal (L) No. 31 of 2020, order dated 14 February 2020 (Bombay High Court, Division Bench). Judgments available at: https://indiankanoon.org/doc/79649288/ and https://indiankanoon.org/doc/143765888/.
Dabur India Ltd. v. Colortek Meghalaya Pvt. Ltd., FAO (OS) No. 625 of 2009 (Delhi High Court, 2 February 2010). Judgment available at: https://indiankanoon.org/doc/82383482/.
Indian Medical Association v. Union of India, W.P. (C) No. 645 of 2022, order dated 7 May 2024, 2024 INSC 406 (Supreme Court of India), available at: https://webapi.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/24832/24832_2022_11_1_52927_FinalOrder_07-May-2024.pdf.




Comments